Live vs. Dry Rock & proposed Waterbox 20 setup

AusReef79 · 04/04/2020, 10:57 PM

G’day Folks, I’m looking at getting a Waterbox 20 for my daughter and the plan is to have some ocellaris, anemone, SPS, gobys... I’m thinking of four, max six, fish. I just wanted peoples thoughts on the proposed setup:

Aquarium: Waterbox 20 AIO
Filtration: Mechanical and Chemical (Carbon) with biological taken care of in the substrate/rock
Skimmer: Tunze 9004
Return Pump: Sicce Syncra 1.5
Lights: AI Prime HD+
ATO: Tunze Nano 3152
Wave maker: Ecotech Marine Vortech MP10
Substrate: Live Sand (Possibly Caribsea Black) and aiming for a reef setup

At the moment I’m deciding on aquascaping - I’m tossing up between live rock and dry rock - pros and cons of both...live rock there’s plenty of bacteria and you might get some good, or bad, surprises. Dry rock can be easier to work with - assemble out of the tank etc. What are people’s opinions/thoughts? I do like the idea of getting some critters from the live rock - I just don’t want them pests 😂 I’d also appreciate some feedback on the setup. Eventually I want to get a real display tank for me 6+ foot 😜 so getting it for my 5yr old daughter is more for me realistically 😂

HumbleFish · 04/05/2020, 08:23 AM

I would go mostly dry rock (to save money), and then add a piece of LR for the biodiversity. It will spread to the other rocks. Try to buy your live rock from another hobbyist with an established, pest-free tank.

Fiish · 04/12/2020, 08:29 PM

Dry rock to play better with aquascape, I think it is a good recommendation to add a portion of live rock to help with your cycling, in any case remember that it is not good to rush things in this hobby. Get the rocks from a reputable store, and if you can select it to your liking.

drs2140 · 04/23/2020, 08:51 PM

I like to go mostly dry and source live rock from multiple local hobbiest to boost the micro fauna and biological filtration

04/04/2020, 10:57 PM	#1
AusReef79 Registered Member Join Date: Mar 2020 Posts: 2	Live vs. Dry Rock & proposed Waterbox 20 setup G’day Folks, I’m looking at getting a Waterbox 20 for my daughter and the plan is to have some ocellaris, anemone, SPS, gobys... I’m thinking of four, max six, fish. I just wanted peoples thoughts on the proposed setup: Aquarium: Waterbox 20 AIO Filtration: Mechanical and Chemical (Carbon) with biological taken care of in the substrate/rock Skimmer: Tunze 9004 Return Pump: Sicce Syncra 1.5 Lights: AI Prime HD+ ATO: Tunze Nano 3152 Wave maker: Ecotech Marine Vortech MP10 Substrate: Live Sand (Possibly Caribsea Black) and aiming for a reef setup At the moment I’m deciding on aquascaping - I’m tossing up between live rock and dry rock - pros and cons of both...live rock there’s plenty of bacteria and you might get some good, or bad, surprises. Dry rock can be easier to work with - assemble out of the tank etc. What are people’s opinions/thoughts? I do like the idea of getting some critters from the live rock - I just don’t want them pests 😂 I’d also appreciate some feedback on the setup. Eventually I want to get a real display tank for me 6+ foot 😜 so getting it for my 5yr old daughter is more for me realistically 😂

04/05/2020, 08:23 AM	#2
HumbleFish Moved On Join Date: Feb 2013 Posts: 4,757	I would go mostly dry rock (to save money), and then add a piece of LR for the biodiversity. It will spread to the other rocks. Try to buy your live rock from another hobbyist with an established, pest-free tank.

04/12/2020, 08:29 PM	#3
Fiish Registered Member Join Date: Dec 2011 Location: Mexico Posts: 202	Dry rock to play better with aquascape, I think it is a good recommendation to add a portion of live rock to help with your cycling, in any case remember that it is not good to rush things in this hobby. Get the rocks from a reputable store, and if you can select it to your liking.

04/23/2020, 08:51 PM	#4
drs2140 Registered Member Join Date: May 2012 Posts: 51	I like to go mostly dry and source live rock from multiple local hobbiest to boost the micro fauna and biological filtration